CommentLuv gives you backlinks, Feedburner Feedsmith steals them

I found this great post from Dexter where he suggests that we should not use the commentluv and feedburner feedsmith plugins together. Actually the reason why was very simple…

How CommentLuv Works?

CommentLuv Plug-in

CommentLuv is a plug-in the will get the title of your last post from your feeds and then add it to your comment when commenting on a blog that has enabled this plug-in. The purpose of this blog is to give backlinks to your latest posts. It’s a great plug-in and I should remind myself to add this to my list of essential plug-ins to add to your wordpress blog.

I better add this so that people won’t get confused…

If you install CommentLuv on your blog, you are doing a favor to your visitors because you will be giving them a free backlink (not the other way around). However, by default, the backlink is no-follow.

How FeedBurner Feedsmith works?

Feedsmith aims to redirect all feed request to feedburner. Basically, when you type silkenhut.com/feed/, it will automatically redirect to feeds.feedburner.com/silkenhut as long as you have this plug-in installed. The purpose of this plug-in is to consolidate all feed request into one place so that feedburner can record your feed subscribers more accurately.

CommentLuv + Feedsmith = Lost of backlinks

The problem here lies when you put together CommentLuv and Feedsmith together. Here’s a short step-by-step on how they work together:

Post a comment at Silkenhut’s World

1. You post a comment on a blog like on this post (note that comments like those will never last 1-2 days on this blog. ^_^)

Begging for feeds
Source

2. CommentLuv will be requesting for your feeds to get the latest post

Detour!
Source

3. FeedSmith catches the request and redirects Commentluv to Feedburner

CommentLuv gets the post title and the feedburner url of the latest post
Source

4. CommentLuv gets the post title and the feedburner url of the latest post

CommentLuv enhanced comment

5. CommentLuv will then add the following info to your comments.

Whew, adding those pictures took a while but I hope I have made my point clear. Do you see what’s the problem when you use CommentLuv together with Feedsmith? (Clue: look at the url)

CommentLuv gives you backlinks but feedburner feedsmith steals them

Update:

It seems that I got confused on what I was writing… Allow me to update what I was writing…

If you install them both, instead of giving your commentators a free backlink, you just gave feedburner a back link that they don’t need. Just to clear things up, CommentLuv is a plug-in that benefits your visitors and not you.

The common solution here is to deactivate (uninstall) feedsmith. However there are two sides on the story and it depends whether feedsmith is there or not.

  • With feedsmith, you will have more accurate feed stats and (loss of backlinks) no backlinks to your commentators
  • Without feedsmith, (you will have backlinks) your commentators will have backlinks and probable loss of accuracy in tracking your feed stats.

That was a bit techy so let’s make it simpler, if you comment on a blog that has CommentLuv enable and…

  • has feedsmith, the url of your last post is http://feeds.feedburner.com/~r/Silkenhut/~3/249297144/ (free backlink to feedburner)
  • has no feedsmith, the url of your last post is http://silkenhut.com/i-dont-like-an-increase-in-traffic/ (free backlink to your blog)

I chose to deactivate feedsmith. I’d rather have more back links than have accurate statistics… I’d rather give my commentators backlinks instead of having more accurate statistics. ^_^

Which do you choose?

Tell me your choices in the comments before.

My apologies for the confusion. I got confused myself too. I already edited the confusing parts and hopefully it won’t be confusing anymore. Let this be a good blogging experience. 🙂 Thank you.

61 thoughts on “CommentLuv gives you backlinks, Feedburner Feedsmith steals them

  1. Nice post Allen, agree, i’d rather have more backlinks.. i’ll deal with the feed stats later. Stumbled!

    nhick
    http://www.itrush.com

    ITrush’s last blog post..Hannah Montana – My Secret Pillow Diary

  2. Nice one.. Properly explained.. Thanks for the link.. I like the pictures 🙂

    Dexter | Techathand.net’s last blog post..Be a Plumber Fix Your Leaking Site

  3. It’s a hard one as Feedburner is such a useful service but those backlinks are nice. Comment Luv does have its own problems though, I’ve seen a few blogs fall down after installing comment luv as it slows down the commenting process.

  4. Good point. I’m a bit confused though. If I may point out: you’re saying

    “If you install them both, instead of giving yourself a free backlink, you just gave feedburner a back link…”

    But I don’t have to have CommentLuv installed on my own blog in order for it to work on yours, right? I mean, if *you* have CommentLuv and *I* have FeedSmith, and I comment on your site, your CommentLuv will pull the feed from my FeedSmith instead of from my Site.

    So I don’t have to have CommentLuv installed myself – did I get it right?

    Because in that case, I would say it depends on the amount of commenting you do on other blogs. Also, I haven’t come across too many sites using CommentLuv so far – PLUS, in order for the backlink to count, these sites must have a plugin like DoFollow or Link Love enabled!

    So if I understand it correctly, that would reduce the chances of getting backlinks to your own site (not many blogs use CommentLove, and even less use them together with DoFollow).

    Maybe I’m completely wrong though 🙂

    Vibr8’s last blog post..Illustrator Trick: How to avoid blurred Pixel Fonts & Shapes

  5. I’ve never realised that. Thanks for letting us know!

    I have just deactivated feedsmith in my blog. You just need to make sure that you change all feed links to feedburner to keep your stats.

    pregnancy facts’s last blog post..Looking for Childcare for Your Child

  6. You wrote this post better than you think you did. Good job! Thanks for informing us about this. 🙂

    Joni’s last blog post..On Manila Cab Drivers

  7. good thing that i dont use any of those. but glad you tell us. thanks for visiting my site! Godbless

  8. Thanks for sharing about this issue. I was never aware of it until now.

    In my case, I deactivated FeedBurner Feedsmith because all my RSS links are hard coded (as far as I know) so it means I won’t be losing track of any new RSS subscribers. 😀

    Jaypee’s last blog post..Goodbye Dreamhost, Hello MediaTemple!

  9. Thanks for taking an effort to explain this. I recently installed CommentLuv — I remember posting about it here last month. I don’t have Feedsmith, though.

    Ederic’s last blog post..Nagbabalik

  10. @Itrush – Thanks for the stumble! I appreaciate the traffic it sent me. 🙂

  11. @Dexter – Hi Dexter, I still give the credit to you since you were the one who discovered this. 🙂

  12. […] Feedburner Feed Smith – Redirects your feeds so that it is being handled by Feedburner. There’s a problem with this if you use it with the CommentLuv plug-in. Read more about it here, feedsmith and commentluv. […]

  13. Likewise I was unaware of the conflict with feedsmith and have deactivated it on my other blog. Now I just have to figure out the best way to keep track of subscribers.

    Greenie’s last blog post..Almost Time For Picnics And Fun

  14. @Greenie – What I did as a workaround for this is to replace all instances of blog.com/feed/ into the feedburner address. ^_^

  15. Digital Products Review says:

    You can go into Feedburner and set this redirect so it counts for search engine hits. By default, it doesn’t. It has to do with the type of redirect it uses.
    But that was not the point of my comment. Just wanted to let you know that I put your blog on a CommentLuv blog list. Have a great day!

    Digital Products Review’s last blog post..Link Love for CommentLuv Blogs Part 1 of 3

  16. if you search “This blog uses CommentLuv v1.0 which will try and parse your last blog post, please be patient while it finds it for you” followed by your keywords you will find sites that are related to you and give some CommentLuv. This may see worthless, but it does help you build up a community.

    Sending some CommentLuv at you.

    Richard McLaughlin’s last blog post..A List of Some Sites you can PING

  17. tv on the web says:

    Hi there. I like commentluv. I think it’s a great tool to gain backlinks and to entice people to leave comments, thus adding value to your blog. thanks for this informative post.

    tv on the web’s last blog post..Watch Psych TV Show Free Online

  18. @Digital Products Review – Oh I see. Thanks for the info (I’m going to try it out) and for the link love. I really appreciate it.

  19. @Richard McLaughlin – Ah yes, that’s a great idea. In fact, I made a post just for that technique. http://silkenhut.com/using-commentluv-to-gain-backlinks-or-spam-blogs/

    Thanks for sharing 🙂

  20. tv on the web – You are welcome! I’m glad you found this post helpful.

  21. Hi very informative article and i think that commentluv is the best around.

    Juniis last blog post..Google Adsense Profits Mixed In With Affiliate Marketing

  22. I’m constantly amazed at the amount of great articles there are on CommentLuv. I never imagined it would get so big, 2 million calls to the remote script already this month!

    Andy Baileys last blog post..Euromillions MASSIVE Rollover and Free Contest – 1 more week!

  23. The question I have is whether Feedburner really steal the backlinks OR do they pass through to your URLs? An SEO I trust tells me that tinyurls pass through and these may too. I’m checking with another SEO to see if we can get a definitive answer.

    Also, whether you have the Feedburner Feedsmith plugin installed only affects YOUR comments wherever you leave them and not comments others leave. You can prove that by looking at the comments in my blog. MINE are redirecting but those left by others not using that plugin are not.

  24. Nice post. What about keywordluv, did you use it?

  25. Never tried the keyword love. I might just give it a go!

  26. Do you use commentluv?

  27. To build credibility simply be proof of your own hype and give people value over and over again. Help others to achieve what they want to, and you become credible in their eyes.

  28. Hi –

    Its important to edit feedburner (See post by Digital Products Review above). “You can go into Feedburner and set this redirect so it counts for search engine hits!”

    Cheers – Rhys

  29. good job have a nice day and thanks for sharing with us

  30. Plugins that encourage more user interaction like Commentluv are a win win if you ask me. More bloggers should use it.

  31. Thank you so much for writing this great article. i enjoyed reading it. it will certainly add to my limited info, and help me do better with my blog everything related to it. thanks again.

  32. This is absolute marketing and branding genius.

  33. Nice sharing. comment luv helps me to increase the Pagerank. highly niche targeted comments works.

  34. Thank’s infonya…

  35. Thank’s infonya…
    Tutorial Blog

  36. That’s an interesting information. I’m just collecting information before I include feedburner, but now I think everthing will remain as it is

  37. Generally I do not post on blogs, but I would like to say that this post really forced me to do so! really nice post…

  38. im confused!!
    I have feedburner in my blog, you have commentluv here, if i post a comment then the link to my site will be the feedburner one?

  39. I really learned something here. I had planned on installing comment luv on my blogs and I will. But I need to understand this feedburner thing a bit better. Does this situation apply also to other feed type applications?

    If we can’t have an active feed on our blog then there is no way for our visitors to subscribe, right?

  40. Creating back links from commenting is a great tool. The best way to find these are to go an use googles operator for example: In the google search box enter the following: intext:”powered by wordpress” AND “KeywordLuv” OR “CommentLuv” this will pull out all blogs that provide the plugin and to filter out non blogs we incorporate the “powered by wordpress”

  41. Hi, this site look pretty good, many good news for fun, learn and relax, i will be back and call the the people for know your place, i’m a webdesiger in Brazil, and i have a blog too, my blog are abou twitter and social media.

  42. I found your site via yahoo thanks for the post. I will save it for future reference. Thanks

  43. I was searching about the internet and come across your blog and found it very interesting and gave it a read!!
    I hope to come back soon to see some updates
    Thank you!

  44. I searched the internet and come across your blog and I found very interesting and gave a reading! I hope to return soon to see some updates Thanks!

  45. thank you for this post brother, cheers..

  46. So i will never use these two plug-ins together. Thanks for the advice bro.

  47. great info..
    its a knowledge to find good backlink..

  48. Living Room Ideas says:

    Hello there, I just wanted to show you I have linked to your site with a nice dofollow link so my visitors can come and check out your blog. I stop by your site often, and I figure that since I like reading your blog, others would want too. You can find the link on our page here: http://www.living-room-ideas.com/sites-we-love/ Great work & keep on blogging!

  49. Thanks for this great post. I’ve bookmarked it for future reference.

  50. if you search “This blog uses CommentLuv v1.0 which will try and parse your last blog post, please be patient while it finds it for you” followed by your keywords you will find sites that are related to you and give some CommentLuv. This may see worthless, but it does help you build up a community.

  51. thank you alot

    its a great post

  52. This post will be helpful to anybody who usess it, as well as myself. regards.

  53. Thank you for the update. I am new to SEO and although its still a mystery for me on how to use this but I will study this for sure it will help me lot.Thank you once again for the informative post…

  54. This article is very useful for me. I started to learn SEO to improve my blog visitors. Thank you for sharing this article …

  55. Thanks for the advice. You saved me because I’m planning to have Commentluv and Feedburner in my sites. It’s a good thing that I have read your post. Again, thanks.

  56. commentluv is the best tool for get best backlink. thank you for your advice you have save me

  57. I was searching for ‘I found your site via Google while looking ‘ via Google on Monday, and I found your page CommentLuv gives you backlinks, Feedburner Feedsmith steals them | Silkenhut's World to be extremely relevant to krabbelrolle. I would like to cooperate with you on my website, so please email me if you are interested.

  58. I love the commentluv plugin and it shows us tons of useful abilities. This plugin has great benefits in developing a beautiful blog and its optimization. In my opinion, it should be a must-have tool for bloggers these days because of its benefits 🙂

    Best regards,
    Nicky @

  59. Hey There Silkenhut,
    I was wondering on a similar note,, If you’re facing a cash crunch and have essential expenses such as medical emergencies, mortgage payments or home repairs to take care of, you can imagine how much easier it would have been if you had saved up a little rainy day fund.
    Thx.

Leave a Reply